Wiki requests queue
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
12:02, 10 July 2021
Comment given by the wiki requester
This is an idea to make a broad-purpose reception wiki built on unusually strict principles. Basically a 'if I wanted to do this, here's how I would do it' project that includes, .Minimum content standard. Being highly deficient, ie 1 paragraph or less than 5 sentences on the page is unacceptable and would be removed. Stub frameworks would be encouraged on user sandboxes instead. .Mainspace focused not on why something sucks or is great, but what people take issue with and why as well as what the opposition thinks in balanced form. Tackling and deconstructing controversy, where 'this really does suck' is a curated exception to the rule. ..To reiterate, anything* may have a page. Its existence is not a condemnation, merely a record of noted controversies and potential issues that an audience may like to know, backed with clear sourcing as to where these came from. A 'why this has a page on crappygameswiki' type of deal. This wiki would hold a page on itself from early on. .Allowance of blogs with whatever slant a given user likes, provided it's not a broadside against individuals or a bypass of content policy. .Full topical range from media to video games to hardware, websites and businesses; specific exclusion of users, picky allowance of good-faith critiques on wikis, platforms including Miraheze itself and higher profile individuals such as celebrities and possibly youtubers. Establishing as private to take a directional change and set up the framework, then open when it's ready. I feel like this one would get a few more eyeballs more quickly than the other two I'm slowly mincing on. Main subject may include, but does not inherently imply living people. I sincerely hope I didn't spam the requests log somehow. The form has been squawking about invalid characters for little apparent reason. This was pasted in after just to ensure I could actually post.
Comment given by Raidarr at 12:03, 10 July 2021
Comment given by DarkMatterMan4500 at 12:19, 10 July 2021
Request approved. Pretty good. Purpose and description are a bit vague, but there is nonetheless a clear enough purpose, scope, and/or topic here. Please be advised this approval does not preclude other wikis from being approved and created that share this topic, provided they aren't 95-100% content forks of your wiki. Please ensure your wiki complies with all aspects of Content Policy at all times.
Comment given by CreateWiki Extension at 12:19, 10 July 2021
Approval Score: 0.88
Comment given by Dmehus at 05:53, 12 July 2021
FYI - note that the user's bureaucrat and sysop rights were not added, though Void added them upon request. If you ever see this happen, please just ping me, or e-mail stewards[at]miraheze.org. Thank you
Retrieved from "
Not logged in
Request a wiki
Request features on a wiki
Requests for adoption
Requests for Comment
Meta Administrators' noticeboard
Miraheze Help Center
Get shortened URL
Donate to Miraheze