Requests for Comment/Shut down the Horrible Music Wiki

Although this wiki is supposed to focus on critically panned songs, just like a majority of reception wikis, this wiki has been infamous for having several amounts of bias, and the worst offender about the wiki is that it a majority of the wiki focuses on songs that are although poorly recieved on music review sites still have a decent/good reception on music streaming sites and YouTube and from some music critics. Several of them include Despacito, and a majority of the songs and pages featured on the wiki list swearing or anything NSFW as a bad quality, which makes the wiki sound anti-NSFW. Same reason can go with rap, in which a majority of the songs featured on the wiki are rap songs. Also, pages about people are allowed on the wiki and they might sound biased and hateful which violated Miraheze's policies. Even the stewards disliked the wiki, pretty much just like other reception wikis mentioned above. It is also pretty hard to say which songs are intentionally bad with good music video production and sounding like any generic pop or other genre songs, in which one of them is the 6ix9ine page (though the page is about an artist), despite the fact that he had done actual several crimes. They also list several songs on categories that don't fit the category, and they even treat some songs on the wiki if they were a disaster, and some of the criticism/bad qualities on the wiki is also quite unconstructive. However, there are some good things about the wiki, such as the fact that there are some helpful pages and pages that are still relatable and artists that are actually bad, such as the Sasaengs page, the Toxic Fandoms and Hatedoms page, and the 6ix9ine page. Also, they fortunately got rid of anything related to Flex Entertainment (though it could've also been easily avoided if they put "Why It/They Intentionally Sucks" or anything similar on pages related to Flex Entertainment). Icantthinkofanamexd (talk) 04:56, 23 December 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 1: Shut down the wiki
This will result in the Horrible Music Wiki getting closed down, and it will be removed after a period of time just like a Miraheze wiki with lack of activity. Icantthinkofanamexd (talk) 04:56, 23 December 2022 (UTC)

Abstain

 * 1)  I'm not sure what to say about it, but it is pretty much get rids of the archive of the wiki, and archiving is still important, especially to those who want to see the past. Icantthinkofanamexd (talk) 04:56, 23 December 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 2: Shut down the wiki, but keep it as an archive
This will also close down the Horrible Music Wiki, but it will remain to exist as an archive.

Support

 * 1)  I think the wiki should remain closed but with it being still available to read, considering that there are some helpful pages on the wiki like Sasaengs, Toxic Fandoms and Hatedoms, and 6ix9ine as mentioned above. Icantthinkofanamexd (talk) 04:56, 23 December 2022 (UTC)