Requests for Comment/Changes to wiki creators (2)

Taking into account concerns and suggestions expressed in the previous wiki creators RfC I've decided to propose a new RfC to take into account that feedback. While initially somewhat opposed to the idea of direct revocation, given recent events I've changed my mind and think that Stewards have trouble determining when a situation is 'bad enough' to revoke a wiki creator so it's best to give it more legitimacy by a community vote. Reception123 (talk) ( C ) 11:01, 16 May 2023 (UTC)

Proposal 1: Appointment
To be appointed Wiki Creator, a request needs to be made at Requests for permissions. The community can discuss (support/oppose/abstain/comment) the request. The request will be considered successful if:
 * at least 5 users share their view
 * there is a support ratio of at least 80%
 * a period of one week has passed since it started

Support

 * 1)  In order to have a revocation system we also need an appointment system. The requirements are in line with other roles. Reception123 (talk) ( C ) 11:01, 16 May 2023 (UTC)

Proposal 2: Revocation

 * The community can initiate a vote of no confidence or a request of removal at any time. In order for it to pass it needs:
 * at least 7 users to share their view
 * a support ratio of at least 50%
 * a period of one week has passed since it started
 * at least one of the criteria in Wiki_creators to be fulfilled

The vote of no confidence is in addition to the possibility for Stewards to revoke Wiki Creators.

Support

 * 1)  Per the forward, I have changed my mind on this and believe that the system is more effective if the community can directly vote. There's also the revocation criteria in place to ensure that wiki creators aren't removed arbitrarily. Reception123 (talk) ( C ) 11:01, 16 May 2023 (UTC)

Proposal 2.1: Revocation

 * The vote of no confidence [as described in Proposal 2] is the only method of revocation and Stewards may only revoke Wiki Creators in an emergency.

Note: Opposing this proposal means that Stewards can still revoke Wiki Creators independently of a vote of no confidence

Oppose

 * 1)  I think it's important for Stewards to retain discretion and be able to revoke users if they're violating the rules set out, especially for a group with a single specific task. Reception123 (talk) ( C ) 11:01, 16 May 2023 (UTC)

Proposal 3: Different minimum requirement

 * '5 users' is replaced with '7 users' for both revocation and appointment