Requests for Comment/Allow certain reception wiki types to be created

Back in October of last year, a RfC was made to close the reception wikis. This RfC passed, with new ones of all types since being declined. As a result, when I recently updated a wiki request after waiting a few months as I was told, it was declined under the reason of it being a reception wiki. I believe that certain types of reception wikis should be allowed. The wiki that I was proposing was "a wiki providing information from a general consensus about the reception of TV shows," and containing "pages detailing TV shows and their good and bad qualities". While this may seem like another Qualitipedia wiki or clone at first glance, it is meant to be a source based, non-personal opinion influenced wiki which does not separate shows by deeming them "good" or "bad," unlike what was seen on most reception wikis. I feel as if Qualitipedia is unfairly looming over every single reception wiki and making them seem all the same, and while I do admit a good majority of wikis are just Qualitipedia clones trying to copy what was done with those wikis, there are still people looking to provide unbiased information about media and its reception that can't do so due to this. That's why I think something should be done to differentiate the opinionated Qualitipedia clones from actual information centers with a focus on providing a general, sourced based viewpoint on media without labeling things as "good" or "bad". BookFandumb1 (talk) 04:46, 22 February 2023 (UTC)

Proposal 1: Keep the ban on Qualitipedia-like wikis, but allow specific reception types to be created
This will not affect Qualitipedia-like wikis being declined, but will lift the ban for other reception wikis which meet the criteria for the following.
 * Are not separate wikis for "good" or "bad" media
 * Are not opinion based and instead contain varying viewpoints from different perspectives
 * Contain reliable sources

Support

 * 1)  as proposer. BookFandumb1 (talk) 04:46, 22 February 2023 (UTC)