User talk:Robloxfan23

Regarding your wiki request
Hi, Robloxfan23. I am not a wiki creator, nor can I approve or decline your request: Special:RequestWikiQueue/22884. But your explanation of the game was great, but I would like you to reopen the request (explaining in 3 paragraphs) what you guys are going to say about it (scope, etc., eg characters, how to get something, if applicable). That way, your request will be more likely to be accepted. --YellowFrogger ( talk ) ( ✔ ) 21:14, 9 February 2022 (UTC)


 * I'd like to reiterate that YellowFrogger is a well-meaning volunteer, but any adjustments to your wiki request should only be made as the reviewing wiki creator feels they are necessary. Personally I would appreciate a few more details as far as what would be in the wiki, but Agent seems to have faith in the scope alongside other options selected in the request, and I trust his discretion. I don't think a re-opening to provide more is necessary, especially when that is only needed to gain a Wiki Creator's faith that the wiki will be acceptable and provide a baseline if any issues come up. --Raidarr (talk) 21:34, 9 February 2022 (UTC)
 * Yeah, my point is exactly the same as yours, I would like to know more about the content that could be posted on the wiki, to consolidate the simple statement that it is the game (talk about the game), instead the socilitator said just from the game. Even so, I don't see any problems with accepting the wiki, that's why I said "no problems", but that reopen would have a better chance of being approved depending on each WC. And, could you clarify: "any adjustments to your wiki request should only be made as the reviewing wiki creator feels they are necessary". --YellowFrogger ( talk ) ( ✔ ) 21:47, 9 February 2022 (UTC)
 * For the second part, I mean that while more detail would be appreciated, Robloxfan23 is specifically only obliged to update his request if the handling reviewer believes more information is needed. I took the liberty of commenting because I do not believe he should spend time posthumously updating an acceptable request. It is only relevant in future cases, and if he makes a request that isn't sufficient to another WC then he will be informed of it then. Edit: I forgot to mention, the request is also for a private wiki, and the bar is not quite as high on them either. Thus, more can be accepted, as in this case. --Raidarr (talk) 21:52, 9 February 2022 (UTC)

Wiki request 29026
I saw your wiki request (linked above) and would like to inform you that the wiki you are requesting will likely not be created for several reasons: 1) it appears to be a reception wiki, the creation of which has been prohibited on Miraheze for damaging its reputation; 2) negative wikis on Scratch are likely to cause drama. A wiki similar to the one you are requesting (Crappy Scratch Projects Wiki) was voluntarily closed by its administration because they were blocked on Scratch because of it and other similar wikis; 3) it may run afoul of provision 3 of the Content Policy: "Miraheze does not host wikis which spread unsubstantiated insult, hate, or rumors against a person or group of people." Scratch's target audience is 8 to 16 year olds, and many children overreact to anything criticizing them or their creations.

I'm not a wiki creator, but I can tell which wiki requests will and will not be approved, and it is for the reasons above that your request will likely not be approved. Don't be discouraged by this message or think that I'm being rude; keep thinking about wiki ideas, and hopefully, you can have your own wiki someday! Tali64³ (talk) 02:12, 6 January 2023 (UTC)